Interactive webcast player
Audit Committee
Wednesday, 30th September 2026 at 6:00pm
Speaking:
Start of webcast
Share this agenda point
1 Minutes
2 Declarations of Interest
Share this agenda point
3 Urgent Decisions
Share this agenda point
4 Public Question Time
Share this agenda point
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
-
Speaker
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Cllr Alex Wynne
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Alex Wynne
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Cllr David White
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Cllr Jo Williams
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Cllr Alex Wynne
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
6 Annual Chair Report on the Effectiveness of Audit Committee 2025/2026
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Speaker
-
Cllr David White
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Speaker
7 2025/26 Audit Completion Report
Share this agenda point
8 2025/26 Statement of Accounts
Share this agenda point
7 2025/26 Audit Completion Report
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Cllr Alex Wynne
-
Speaker
-
Speaker
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Alex Wynne
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Alex Wynne
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
-
Speaker
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
-
Speaker
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Speaker
-
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member)
-
Cllr Mark Jones
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Mark Jones
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Mark Jones
-
Speaker
-
Cllr Mark Jones
-
Cllr Jon Byrne
-
Webcast Finished
Disclaimer: This transcript was automatically generated, so it may contain errors. Please view the webcast to confirm whether the content is accurate.
1 Minutes
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:00:07
Good evening, welcome to this evening's Audit Committee meeting.We are just going to quickly take items 7 and 8 together as we get towards the end just
so we can ask questions more succinctly.
So first item on the agenda is minutes.
Do we agree with the minutes?
Any other questions?
Any other questions?
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:00:38
Okay, next item is declarations.Anyone got any declarations they need to declare?
Next item is urgent decisions.
2 Declarations of Interest
Any urgent decisions?
No urgent decisions.
And public question time.
3 Urgent Decisions
Any public questions?
Okay.
4 Public Question Time
So, onto the first substantive item.
Item 5, Internal Audit Progress Report 2.
I'll hand it to you, John.
Thank you, Chair.
Good evening, everyone.
Speaker - 0:01:05
This is the second progress report of the financial yearfrom Internal Audit and Risk Services.
So, again, I'll just talk through a couple of key areas
and then obviously invite questions for a minute
in the usual way, if that's OK.
So, in the period since the last audit update
that we gave the 27th of June since that day.
We've completed a further seven audits,
and 10 more are in draught, six more are in progress.
And you can see that in appendix A in the report.
Section five gives a bit of an update around
risk management and the corporate risks
and the processes that we're improving on on that.
And our risk manager, James, will be coming
to the next meeting to give a more detailed update
on the corporate risks and progress thereof.
In terms of Section 6, I've highlighted the ongoing projects that we're involved in,
and there's also a new project that we've been asked to assist with, which is the new
finance and purchase -to -pay system, which I think from a risk perspective is a high -risk
project for the organisation in terms of financial risk, reputational risk, and all that kind
of stuff.
So we will be coming heavily involved with that
as that project progresses at haste.
Section eight touches on the recommendations
and the kind of representation and the graphics
with the new dashboard that we've got in place now.
So as members may be aware,
certainly those established members,
we've been working hard using Power BI,
which is a new software tool to hopefully introduce changes to the way that we present
data to you to make it a little bit more easy to read and understand hopefully in your roles
as well.
So again, some of that is a work in progress, but again, hopefully you can see there the
benefits of seeing some of that visualisation rather than just narrative.
In terms of the limited audits that obviously we update every meeting, the audit on DOORS
is now complete.
We've done a follow -up on that.
We're comfortable that the backlog of applications is reducing significantly.
Some of the actions and changes in controls have been implemented now.
Members may be aware there was some legal updates from around, I think it was the 2nd
June on a case that happened actually in Cheshire.
And there's been a change in terms of the definition of deprivation of liberty, safeguards,
and the effects of that.
So the national reason is that because the definition has changed, threshold slightly
changes, there should, the impact should be less applications in future.
So, there is a bit of an impact now because obviously the team's having to work on this
new definition of that actual statement, looking back to some of the applications that we've
got on board now.
So we're comfortable with that audit.
The CCTV audit obviously is ongoing.
There was an update from our assistant director of assets at the last CSIRO board meeting,
as I sort of laid out at the last meeting.
In terms of an action plan, I have put most of that in terms of the progress and update
thereof.
And again, we are monitoring the actions and the progress with the new Assistant Director
of Assets moving that forward.
Obviously, as that progresses, I will update this Committee on progress.
There's a couple of new audits that we've done in the period since June on EHCP governance,
education and health governance,
and parks and open spaces as well,
which are both limited assurance as well.
And then Appendix A is the status of audit work.
Appendix B is the summary updates of the audits,
parks and open spaces, EHCP governance,
highways, estates, PSF arrangements,
that's professional services framework arrangements,
building control, the operation of the AHMP service,
and the CITFIM code self -assessment as well.
So that's a bit of just a very brief walk through,
Chair, in terms of the work that we've done,
but obviously happy to take any questions from members.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:05:43
Have we got any questions, Philip?Thanks, Chair.
Thanks, John.
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:05:49
You know, good report.I mean, I find it very easy to understand it.
I think the big thing that's coming out of it for me
is you've got a table on, I think it's page nine
of the report which shows that the resource gap has shrunk,
but in reality, you've reduced the size of the prize.
There's been a constant theme,
as I've been seeing these reports,
that your resource has got less and less.
And I suppose the simple question, how far can you keep kicking the can down the road
before it comes back and causes a problem?
So that's one question.
Do you want the others now or not?
Can you start to that one?
Yeah, sure.
Sure.
Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker - 0:06:33
And I think, you know, I've always been honest and open in terms of the amount of work becausewe do a fully risk -based audit plan.
and the delivery of that is always a challenge
given the resources we've got.
We're not unique in that.
I don't think there's any head of audit
that sits in front of a committee saying,
I've got the resources I need to deliver a plan.
It just doesn't work nowadays.
I think what's been unique this year
is obviously the significant changes that we had
in terms of personnel that's outdated last time
in a bit more detail.
So the budget for the plan was based on
an employee who's now moved roles.
So obviously there was quite a bit of his time.
He did a lot of risk stuff,
but he also did some of the high level audits as well.
So that's had to be factored in.
There has been obviously a member of staff
who was off for a number of months off sick as well,
and that impacted the plan as well.
But that said, we are, as like I said before,
we're working and using AI, Power BI.
We used to use a system called IDEA
to do continuous auditing.
So using technology to support us in that journey.
Power BI is taking that over now, if I'm honest.
So we don't have the same licence fee as IDEA,
so we're getting the team trained up
to deliver those services using technology.
We use AI particularly to enhance our reports
and support the reporting process.
It helps us to develop testing schedules as well.
And part of what we're trying to do as well
as part of our education to the overall organisation
is support them, this is the ideal isn't it,
for them to manage the controls,
because ultimately they're responsible
for the control environment, not us.
So there is that approach as well.
We also still work very closely with partners,
like for example this afternoon I met colleagues
on the Star joint procurement,
and we're working together to do a number of audits later on this year that will benefit
the six organisations that STAR supports, and I think that's an important point to make
as well.
We're also still buying results from Salford, internal audit who supports on the more technical
IT stuff as well.
But it is always a conversation that Jonathan and myself are having.
I think this year, like I say, is unique because of some of those earlier changes.
when we get next year.
We've actually got quite a stable audit team,
which I think is really positive.
We've brought in some newer junior members
to support us in that progress,
as then being the next senior auditors, if you like, as well.
But it's something that we're always looking at
in terms of resilience and building on that.
But I think that combined with more targeted audits
in the future and the use of IT will support us.
And ultimately, I have to make a judgement.
am I getting sufficient evidence to produce my annual opinion?
And at the minute, I'm not concerned that I'm not,
if that makes sense.
Thanks, John. Thanks for that.
I mean, as I say, I think it's just, you know,
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:09:45
that constant vigilance to make sure that it doesn't slip too far.Just a couple of very specific ones.
You touched on the EHCP governance.
That seems a particularly challenging position.
And I think in your comments,
you talk about the need for leadership and so forth.
I didn't get the sense from your comments that actually you felt that leadership and
the activity required was there.
That's the first one.
And then the second one is you've deferred the review on terrorism management.
Just wondering around the timing of that, is that appropriate or should that be accelerated?
Speaker - 0:10:27
So, in terms of the first order, you know, absolutely the EHCP and SEND in general is,like, nationally, the demands of the service are not abating, if you like.
But I think to be fair, there was a backlog.
When we got an update on this, the backlog's reduced and is reducing considerably.
they have introduced what they call an SCN pilot project, which again is looking at the
overall governance and an actual planning place to try and reduce that backlog and support
what's going on.
Yeah, in terms of governance, I think because there's the board and then reporting into
the board, there's a number of subgroups.
I think historically at the first phase, which is the decision to issue phase, I think the
council has strategically made the decision to challenge some of these applications.
What happens then is it becomes a backlog because obviously people, parents, schools,
or the providers will challenge those decisions.
So the backlog then happens, we get quite a lot of appeals.
And of course, you can probably see naturally as well,
these appeals go through and the threshold is quite low,
so a lot of the appeals get overturned.
So I think they're looking at that in the round
and saying, well actually, is that the best decision?
Is that the best way to look at managing?
Because all we're doing is,
we're shovelling the problem to the end
and then obviously, we know, I think,
that appeals, 90 % of appeals,
nationally get overturned.
So, I think the wise to that,
I think it's like anything because
the working with other professionals,
I think one of the key areas is education psychology,
where again the problems stem
in terms of getting the professionals in
to give that advice, and I think again
in that area there are delays.
So, the overall scheme and system
is very interdependent on a lot of different professionals.
And it's the challenge, it's not just the stop point,
it's probably every authority is bringing those together,
bringing those people together effectively,
because they've got the framework in place,
but it's just like some of the membership of the meetings
seems to be sometimes more focused, council -led,
when actually it should be from professionals
from other areas bringing in that bit
of cheques and balances as well.
So it wasn't an overall criticism by any stretch
in terms of leadership.
I think the leadership and the will is there.
And there's a lot of work being done to,
you know, recovery plans and all that kind of stuff
to work through this, both through national support,
but also regional support as well.
And then in terms of the second question
on terrorism management.
So, because as part of what we do,
and it is a risk, absolutely,
and I think we all know that, you know,
risks nationally and internationally contribute to that.
But when we look at some of the things on the plan,
we also have to take into account
are there other areas of the council looking at that?
And as part of our work on the insurance side,
we review all our covers and policies annually,
which terrorism is one of those.
And we did a bit of an exercise as part of the renewal
this year, which is actually going through
with our partners, ZM, who are our insurers,
where they looked at our current actions and action plan.
So they gave us a bit of feedback on that
in terms of insurable risks.
So when you're looking at what needs to be forgotten,
doing other things, actually, the reliance on the work
that we've done there meant that actually we can reduce
the risk in terms of the control environment slightly
because ZM have given us their view,
which is really positive.
But then we can include it in the risk assessment
to be done next year if that makes sense.
OK, I've got Councillor Winant.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:14:30
Are either of your questions like the HCPs?It's on the poll, but it's not going to work.
Because I was just going to ask mine first, just to keep it topical.
So, that was the...
From this report, that was the thing that popped out most of me
because, as I mentioned before, I'm on the Children and Families Scrutiny Committee
and the summary of findings in here doesn't, in my mind, reflect the information we most
recently received at, or have received over the last year at Children and Families. And
I wonder whether that's something we could maybe pull out a little bit in a, maybe in
a briefing or some kind of offline session, just so we could look at, maybe get someone
from the service to have a chat, just so we can understand. I think it's similar.
Cllr Alex Wynne - 0:15:21
Yeah, it was. I mean, I've been on this committee now for, I think it's three years, and I'verarely seen a limited audit. I think you'll agree, John, they don't come around that often.
What is the process for reporting to the relevant committees? Because it would be children's
and it would be the, I forget what the other committee is. Do we have a set report that
can go to them where you can feed back the information, the actions that have been agreed,
and then the particular officers can talk to that.
Speaker - 0:15:52
So, we wouldn't ordinarily, I think, obviously,my function of reporting is into this committee
and then it would be up to the chair with yourselves
how you want to move that forward
in terms of challenge
or receiving assurance from individuals.
But again, I think it's something...
We are seeing some limited assurances coming through,
certainly this year, and I think it's reflective
evolve the broader challenges that the council has got.
And, you know, and that said, I think it shows the value of us doing a risk -based audit plan.
If I came to you and I said every audit was substantial, you'd be thinking, well, what
exactly are you looking at?
So yeah, we, and this is where I think the last committee were very much, when you get
limited assurance audits here for this committee, we want to see those updates quarterly to
see how they're progressing so that we can give you
up -to -date information around, well actually,
where the sense is, like with the CCT one,
it's not progressing, let's do something
to move that forward.
This was recently done, so they may well have been changed,
but obviously we will only follow this up
for the next committee, but I take on board
what you were saying in terms of doing some sort of
briefing for committee moving forward.
Cllr Alex Wynne - 0:17:09
Yeah, I think when it's limited,I think there definitely needs to be some sort of feedback
into the relevant committees, from my opinion.
Thank you, Chair.
Speaker - 0:17:21
I just wanted to provide some assurancearound that leadership focus that's mentioned in the report
and just highlight that there's been a number
of conversations at corporate leadership team
over the last weeks and months around EHCP assessment
and some of the challenges we have as a council with that
in terms of the timeliness of that assessment
and what that challenge and problems that causes,
not only for the council, but for those parents
that are awaiting those assessments as well.
So there's been quite a significant amount of work.
There is the Education White Paper
and the SEND reform that links into that
and national funding that has come to the council
to support some of that work.
But we've also been able to identify some one -off resource,
to address that backlog position on assessment.
So that's some positive news and it's recent as this week
in terms of identifying some of that resource
which will address that backlog through a third party
supporting us while our colleagues in the service
concentrate on that business as usual
and maintaining that sort of timeliness
and that status quo.
I think it would be beneficial if committee needs more insight in that to bring some colleagues
into this meeting or a separate workshop, if you like, to have a more detailed conversation
about some of that work.
I'm sure they would highlight some of the risks, though, in that position as well, because
we know that government has put a bit of a cliff edge in place in terms of EHCPs and
and expected influx of EHCPs as the reforms take place
and eligibility for EHCPs changes
in a not too distant future.
So we may see more coming in
and that will impact on those assessments.
So we are, or the service are working hard
and are focusing on that,
but I think we recognise some of the challenge in that.
As John says, that's just not specific to Stockport,
that's across the country as well.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:19:37
Yeah, thank you for that context.I think I'm happy for us to take it offline after the meeting
and maybe we could speak to the chair of Drug Upon Disgrutiny
and see whether either something goes there,
we do a briefing offline and just see where we're all at
or something comes back here.
But where it best fits, I think it's important
that we don't just let it fall.
Sometimes when there's a limited assurance order,
It's perfectly acceptable to wait three months
for the next time to come around,
but I think some of these things,
especially when children are involved,
we need to just be,
especially as things are changing quite rapidly
as it sounds, I think we need to just be on top of that
and make sure we're heading in the right direction.
Is this on this topic?
It is on my level.
Go on.
You go first.
I absolutely agree on this point,
Cllr David White - 0:20:25
but I think there's a wider issueabout what we do with these in all of them,
because this is very specific to this, but I think it's important that we feed into these things
and how we involve committees moving forward.
It's something I have raised with the director before, as he's well aware,
but I think how these things feed into committees and how members are aware of what is going on
is something that we need to have further thought on,
but I think it's an important point that's been raised with regard to EHCPs.
but I think there is a wider look at how we can feed other reports
and other issues that are being raised in other areas,
such as one that is very relevant in the committee that I am on,
which is estates function, which has problems in my view,
which needs to be brought to the fore.
and that's certainly something that needs to be,
I have further work done.
But I think it's very pertinent to this,
but there are wider issues that need some further thought
about how technically we deal with that.
Thank you.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:21:43
Council Williams has been waiting very patiently.Thank you, Chair.
Cllr Jo Williams - 0:21:49
Yeah, thank you.Actually, I wanted to come back on some of the things
that have already been picked up,
and it's interesting discussion about that follow up
and connecting to the other portfolios.
Because when I was going through the notes,
I was thinking, oh, there's some actions in the minutes,
how am I assured that though,
because we don't have that kind of matters arising item.
So it's like, I guess it's that kind of similar point,
isn't it, about how things have followed up.
And I mean, you did qualify a little bit more
in your briefing about the DOLS assessment report,
for example, and that the waiting list had,
you are assured that the waiting list had come down.
I hadn't picked that up necessarily
from the summary and the document,
and it made me think, ooh, that item's closed.
how am I assured that actually it's closed correctly
and whether there are still outstanding issues.
And then the other point I just wanted to come back on
was the issue of your audit resource.
And it was just a question, again, you did refer
to my wonderings, which was whether there is kind
of that joint working with some of the services
about whether they can pick up some of the activity that maybe isn't, you haven't necessarily
got the capacity for, obviously with your oversight, but obviously giving them the tools
to do that.
And also whether, sorry, it's kind of three points here, whether your sort of plan is
agile to any national or work that might be going on at the same time that you might not
have expected.
So, you know, a case in point being the CQC report,
there might have been things that you were going to do
that then got pulled out in the CQC report
that then mean that you can review your priorities.
Yeah, I mean, in terms of that last point,
the new GIS standards,
Speaker - 0:24:05
which we will be bringing the self -assessment to you,either in December or in March,
do place a lot of reliance on other sources of assurance.
and as parts of the risk assessment,
we would look at that and say,
like you say, some national things that come out
and actually, if we're comfortable,
that we can get that assured,
so you can get that assured from somewhere else,
we can rely on that more.
And then when I do my annual opinion,
which I've presented in the July report,
there is a big set,
and that's increased quite a lot
over the last few years around looking at
whether it's inspections, offset inspections,
CQC, relying on some of that.
But again, if some of those are critical, we then say, well, actually, we need to do some more.
But actually, I think there was an example in the risk assessment of one area that the assessment came out more favourable.
So why spend time on that?
And just quickly, in terms of sharing of results, absolutely.
It's something that as heads of audit, we're always looking at and we're always looking to develop.
So for me, two of the big areas now, we already are involved in that.
So IT risks, data risks, cyber risks,
we buy that in from Salford,
there is a cost to that obviously,
but we do get that technical skill in
as and when we need it.
And we are looking to shadow Salford,
some of the auditors, so they can gain skills
and bring that in house,
I think that's a really important point.
The other area again, like I said before,
procurement is another area where we do share
best practise, resource, we talk about some of the
key things that are going on within other authorities that might affect us as well.
And that helps inform me and feed my plan.
Some authorities have moved away from audit plans altogether.
It's quite radical, but they basically turn up the CRT equivalent every quarter and say,
okay, directors, you tell me what you want.
Now, there's pros and cons to that, I'm sure, you know.
But for some authorities, it works.
Now, I'm not suggesting we do that here,
but there are other options to look at.
What I would say is every year we do risk assess
and reflect in the plan.
There's also a built -in resource that we have,
because you're right, as soon as I get the plan approved
in March, the next week it's changed,
because directors want other things doing,
and it's about me assessing with them actually
what's the best use of our resources here.
But rest assured, all those changes come to you
for challenge, for scrutiny, and like the questions hopefully,
are the setting out and the explanation of the reasons.
But the ones we defer, we're not doing them,
we just refer them, we defer them to the risk assessment
for next year as well.
Thank you.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:26:53
One other thing I wanted to pick up on,and it was just a thank you really,
is that I know you've taken some students' work experience.
I think it's a really important part of what we do here,
the council in general but any department that's willing to do that it's really useful
to see. So have we got any more questions, comments? Nope, fantastic. So I think we're
asked to note that report. I'm just going to go back to the thing. Is that right? Yeah,
okay, note that. Thank you. So next is item 6 which is my report. Exciting. Item 5 is
I'm sorry. Yeah, item six, my report, which is the annual
Chair's report on the effectiveness of the Audit Committee. Now, it might come as a shock
to you, but I am not Sue. So I wasn't the Chair of the Committee last year when this
report is referencing. But I did want to just put on thanks the work of Sue over the three
years she was Chair of this Committee and all the previous members from last year who
not here anymore because I think they've done a lot there. And also to Philip, the co -op
team who's doing a sterling job and always has lots of questions. And the audit team
as well for all the work that you do on this. I think this report hopefully, and these meetings
hopefully show the value that audit brings to the organisation. It doesn't sound very
exciting when you look at it on an agenda audit. It probably sounds boring but you know
the conversations we have here can't often be had anywhere else so I think it's really
useful. As part of being the chair and I know the previous chair did as well, I attend the
North West Audit Chairs Briefings so we have a meeting and we all discuss and get to hear
some very interesting things from other councils across the Northwest.
But one of the most important part of that is learning about best practise
and about what other people do and how other people do things.
I think a lot of what we do here reflects really well on what other people do
and some of the challenges they have, we must have dealt with many years ago
and have solved, which is really good to see.
And I do think there's some things we can do to learn from other people as well.
And I have already spoken to the team, so hopefully that will come forward
over the next committee, we might be able to see some of those things whenever possible,
just to improve that. But yeah, that's all I'm going to say. If you've got any questions,
comments?
Cllr Alex Wynne - 0:29:33
Just to provide my thanks to Sue as well, when you next see her. Thank you.6 Annual Chair Report on the Effectiveness of Audit Committee 2025/2026
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:29:41
It's a wonderful glowing report. Haven't we done well? It just feels slightly odd thatwe're writing a report about ourselves to tell us that we've done really well, how do
we get the external validation that what we're doing is good, is the question I have. I don't
have the answer.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:30:04
Yeah, it is fair. It is fair. And I think that's, you know, when I speak to other chairs,I think that's a useful, one of the useful things I found was that I could see what other
people are doing and seeing that we are doing it in a similar way to some of them really
pulling the hair out.
So I think that is useful.
I think yourself as a co -opty, as a non -elected member is a really useful part of that process
as well because I'm pretty sure there's things you would happily say that we all might shy
away from.
And you put a different lens in it so I think that's really important as well.
And obviously we have our external auditors here all the time.
I'm sure they would tell us off if we weren't doing things right.
Speaker - 0:30:47
I was going to chip in, Chair, so thank you for the opportunity there.While in typical external audit fashion, we wouldn't comment positively on things that the committee does.
You can rest assured we would be commenting were there things that the committee didn't do,
or was doing that were inappropriate and not part of its remit.
so you can take some assurance from the fact that the external auditor hasn't said anything
negative about the committee.
Cllr David White - 0:31:21
Thank you, Chair. That in itself is a positive, I suppose. I think that I would like to placeon record, I wasn't on the council or on the committee, but I think it's important that
members place on record their appreciation for the former chair Sue Gwithero. I do know
Sue Gwithero and work with her in unison but I would place on record my thanks to her as
the previous chair. Unfortunately she lost her seat and I do say that with no hesitation.
So, I do want to place that on record.
Thank you, Chair.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:32:10
Just quickly, I just want to add to Phil's comments.Speaker - 0:32:14
Absolutely, we'll take on both some of that and what you say.I think, again, this is set for best practise about the committee bringing together its work that it's done.
And I think, like I already just said, you know, there are other partnerships within this committee
that sort of add value to it, so yourself filling your role as the co -opted member,
bringing that extra dimension as to external audit as well.
Yeah, I think in terms of format, we can certainly look at that in future.
That was a format that, again, SIPA brought out a number of years ago, but I think we
can maybe look and update that in the future and see where we can demonstrate the effectiveness
of the committee in other ways as well, taking that forward.
Thank you very much.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:33:02
So we are asked to note that report.Is that noted?
Fantastic.
So on to the big items.
So items 7 and 8 we're going to take together.
So we've got the statement of account and the audit completion report and I'm not sure
which way round we're going.
To me it's to you.
Speaker - 0:33:31
Thank you, Chair. You've built it up. No pressure. So absolutely pleased to present an updateon the Council's 25 -26 Annual Statement of Accounts. The draught accounts were submitted
to our external auditor, Paul Vismazares, by the statutory deadline of 30 June and the
required public inspection period followed,
7 2025/26 Audit Completion Report
during which we haven't received any questions
from residents.
8 2025/26 Statement of Accounts
Preparing an audit in the accounts
within those reporting deadlines remains a challenge,
but you can see that from the appended
small 263 -page statement of accounts document
at the back of the report.
Following discussions with committee members,
the finance team is also considering best practise
from other councils in terms of producing
in a summary set of accounts.
This will draw out on the key messages
from the technical document and make them more accessible.
And I know we've discussed that a number of times
in the committee.
We do recognise that condensing such a large
and complex document will require some thought
and capacity, but we are continuing to work on that
as a team and will report back on progress
to the committee.
I'd like to thank the finance team
and our external audit colleagues
for their professionalism and hard work,
which have enabled us to bring this positive update
to the committee this evening.
Aaron, our Capital Assets Accountant,
is here tonight representing the team,
and importantly will be assisting me
with any of your technical questions
that will come at the end.
When the report was written,
the external audit was substantially complete,
with only a small number of items outstanding.
And I'm pleased to report that since the agenda was published, many of these have now been
completed and signed off by the external audit team.
It's really important and I'm very proud that we are only one of a small number of councils
that are able to say that nationally.
We are close to completing the audit and securing final approval by the end of September, which
which is a great achievement.
The external audit has identified some misclassifications
and the accounts have been amended
where these are material and the significant amendments
are detailed at paragraph 3 .2 of the report.
There have been some minor changes also
to improve readability with all the changes highlighted
in the appended document at the back of the report.
I'm pleased to report that both the internal control
recommendations from last year's audit
have been implemented successfully.
The quality of the asset valuation reports particularly
and the timeliness of responses from our valuation team
has improved significantly.
And we continue to build on that progress
during the 26 -27 audit with discussions between teams
already taking place in terms of how we continue
that improvement.
The Council submitted its cycle one
whole of government accounts return
on the 4th of September as required.
And we're continuing to work to meet the cycle two
deadline of 30 October.
Alongside the accounts audit for Rismus R provided the Council with a value for money opinion.
That work is nearing completion, is ongoing, but today there has been no matters reported
by our external audit colleagues.
So as I said, the statement of accounts remains subject to final audit review and sign -off.
So on that basis, it's recommended that the committee
delegate to myself, Director of Finance,
in consultation with the chair of the committee
to approve any further non -material changes
that are identified during that final audit review work.
If the external auditor does identify an issue
requiring a material change, we would bring
the revised statement of accounts back
to a future audit committee meeting for approval.
So thank you, and I'll pass on to Alistair.
Thank you Jonathan.
So before I kick off on the external audit report,
7 2025/26 Audit Completion Report
I would like to introduce Hendrix to the committee.
So Hendrix is the team leader for the audit.
He is by far and away the key person
who's driving things forward.
And without Hendrix we wouldn't be
in this positive position as the key team leader.
Headline messages from me do dovetail
with Jonathan's message and messages,
so the work has progressed well.
Those of you on the committee last year
will be aware that the progress this year has been better
and we are ahead of where we were this time last year
with fewer matters outstanding at this point.
And that's a really pleasing position to be in.
And it's a testament both to the hard work of my audit team
but also the good, positive relationship we have with the council finance team,
the way that they approach the audit, support the audit and are as keen,
if not keener than we are to get things completed
as quickly as possible.
And that positivity I think also extends to
a point that Jonathan made around constantly wanting
to improve the statement of accounts.
They are 230 some pages because it's a complex entity
with lots of complex accounting
and the accounting framework that it has to comply with
requires that length, but where possible, the Council is actively looking to improve
the way out, the structure, the content in the accounts, and they do listen to our views
as the external auditor.
So subject to the satisfactory outcome of the remaining matters, we will be issuing
an unqualified audit opinion in the near future, and for those of you unfamiliar with external
audit, an unqualified opinion is the right one. I make that point because I have been
asked in the past why an unqualified, why not having any qualifications is a good thing
for an audit. Not good for auditors, but good for an audit opinion. So I will take the reporters
red but I think it is helpful for you and particularly as some members are new to the
committee and the external audit reporting, I thought it might be useful for me to touch
on a few of the sections, if that's okay, Chair.
Particularly if I turn to section two, the outstanding areas that were reported in section
two have moved on since we drafted and issued the report for the published papers.
So four areas are now complete from that list.
The work on the airport shareholding, the pensions, accounting, financial instruments
and leases are all completed and there are no matters to bring to your attention.
The other areas are predominantly the ordinary closure elements of the accounts, with the
exception of the first two, the property plant and equipment and the investment property,
where those discussions are ongoing and continuing to be resolved.
I don't imagine there will be significant delays from that.
That's just these are complex matters that take longer to resolve and these are quite often those things that are at the end being resolved.
Section 3, we've set out our audit approach and to confirm to you there aren't any substantive changes from the position I presented at the last meeting with our audit plan
and does include the approach to auditing the council's group,
which includes Totally Local and Stockport Homes.
In terms of the findings,
I think in section 4 and section 6 for the misstatements,
they dovetail what Jonathan has reported,
so some classification adjustments
and some minor areas that have been corrected by the Council
and the areas that haven't been corrected aren't material
and don't cause us an issue for our audit opinion.
A couple of final things.
Value for money, as Jonathan said, our work is nearing completion.
We're now at the review and the consistency moderation stage.
So we've completed our work, but it's really important that my judgments on the council's
arrangements for value for money are not taken out of context with similar arrangements at similar
authorities. So we as an audit firm have quite a robust moderation process that considers whether
my judgments are consistent with other auditor's judgments of authorities in similar situations.
I haven't gone through that yet, that's next week, that process is going through,
so it would be far too early for me in a public meeting to give any sense of what the outcome
of that will be.
But we will report the findings in our auditor's annual report, which we issue at the end of
the audit and will come to your next meeting as a matter of reporting for you to then scrutinise
and discuss.
And finally, not by any means lightly, we reconfirm our independence from the Council with no matters to report.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:43:39
Wow, thank you. That was a, it is a big report and I think the statement of accounts itself is a work to behold.and thank you to the team that prepared that
because I think, you know, I absolutely take,
you know, I do agree that we should try
and humanise it a little bit for the public
and for ourselves as non -financed people
to be able to read, but I do thank the team
for putting on a training session for us as well
and for those members who were able to attend
because it did that, allow us to ask
some of those silly questions
that we might not want to ask in public
and we don't necessarily understand some of the words which was me.
So it was really, really useful to see that.
So I've got Councillor Wynne first.
Thank you, Chair.
Cllr Alex Wynne - 0:44:31
Firstly, can I just comment on the fact that the report has come, I think it's two monthsearlier than last year.
And thank you for that.
I think those who were on the committee last year know how much of a slog it was and the
fact that you've managed to deliver it so much earlier is really, really impressive.
but I wouldn't be a compliance person in a bank
without seeing an 11 .292 million overstatement
caused by a formula without asking what controls
have now been put in place to ensure
that that does not happen again.
Speaker - 0:45:12
Yes, I agree. The control next year is that my boss will look at the formula as well,but that comes through, it's the first time in five years that the HRA gets valued and
Obviously you can see the huge figures on council dwellings.
So 11 million out of 762 million
can sometimes be difficult to pick up,
but we've got controls going forward,
a different system for value in HRA going forward.
So hopefully that will happen again.
Speaker - 0:45:56
Sorry, I just think it's helpfulfrom my perspective as well on this, hopefully, not commenting on the controls specifically,
but I think highlighting one of the things that links to one of the things Jonathan said
around the challenges to produce a set of accounts in the timeframe that the Council
has, to publish them by the end of June.
That does put pressure on one of those really key elements at the end of the process, which
is the quality assurance, which is the checking that goes in to make sure that things are
right and these things aren't in the draught accounts that come for audit, albeit that
the audit process does provide that opportunity to identify them.
So it does put a stress and a strain on those QA processes which are really, really key.
And you'll see on the agenda page, it looks closely to 86 on our internal control deficiencies
where we report the prior year deficiency around linking to some of the delays from
last year around those valuations and the controls.
We've said that that is partially implemented, not fully.
And that's part of one of the reasons is the error
that's come through is simply that with a really strong
robust QA process would probably have picked up.
So that's something for, I know that Jonathan and Aaron
and Paula who's not here, but would echo that
is something that the council's focused on.
Yeah, just a point on that.
Speaker - 0:47:24
The timeframe to get the accounts done is really tight in terms of the end of June.And some of the processes in terms of valuations, as Jonathan said, are already in place now.
We've got the schedule in place so that the estate team can get on with that as soon as
possible.
And there's certainly been improvements in the team, a couple of new members who are
really excellent on valuations and understand the valuations, which can be tricky.
These types of valuations aren't always that common, especially on HRA council dwellings.
Cllr Alex Wynne - 0:48:06
Thanks. And that was going to be my follow -up, whether there was any pre -workthat could be done to ensure that it's almost pre -quality assurance. I know that's not really
thing, John, don't worry. But if we could ensure that that's done in the next six to
nine months ahead of the next accounts, then hopefully the formulas will be more relied on.
Speaker - 0:48:31
Thanks. And just to come back on that, really, I think, just to, if it's not already obvious,the finance team, we are absolutely about continuous improvement. We are always looking
in which we can be more efficient, more effective,
deliver on the accounts in a way that is,
assures quality but also does that at a pace
that is appropriate and that I think we've demonstrated
that through the fact that we've been able
to deliver that two months.
Earlier I've seen products that the team are producing
which cheques every figure on every page
against every other figure on every page
where they do cross -cheque.
It's something that when I was a graduate trainer
I used to do, that a lot of the figures
have to cross -cheque to each other.
We've got an automated process now that does that
and I'm sure that Aaron and the team will be picking up
on everything that's come out through the audit
to make sure that we are continually improving
and improving those processes.
So yeah, really assured by that process that we take
and that focus that we have.
Just finally, it's good to know
Cllr Alex Wynne - 0:49:45
that there's automated controls in placebecause as wonderful as you are as a team,
manual controls are always subject to error.
Automated controls are usually more robust in that.
So thank you.
Thank you.
Just a couple of quick questions.
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:50:00
The definition of material,when we're being asked to defer the final sign off
to you, Jonathan,
What would be classed as material?
Speaker - 0:50:17
I don't know because I think there's two elements of material.There's what the council might consider to be material.
But in this context the important thing is whether they impact on my audit report.
So it's the external audit view of material.
I'm just scanning through my report because I can't remember what the actual value of materiality is.
I will take that as a roughly accurate,
obviously Hendrix knows the precise answer,
it's 21 ,960 ,000 is the headline materiality.
So I think you get a take on the 21, 22 million,
but demonstrating the skills and capabilities
of my team there to know these things.
So were there to be an adjustment at that level,
then that would be material that would impact
on our audit report.
Under that wouldn't be.
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:51:17
If there was something that was below that numberthat was more of a procedural or a concern
or a non -financial material issue,
what would be the limits on that?
It's probably quite a difficult one to ask,
But I think it would be helpful to have some comfort that if there is something
undisclosed at this point that we'd become aware of it as part of our process.
Speaker - 0:51:44
I probably should have included that in my intro spiel,and particularly for members who are unfamiliar with the external audit process.
So this report, you see the items that are listed as outstanding.
The way that we bring those to your attention is we issue a follow -up letter
at the end of the audit when I issue the audit
or just before I issue the audit opinion,
I will issue a follow -up letter.
It will include those items that are outstanding.
It will give you a conclusion on those
as to whether there are any matters arising from that
for your responsibilities,
which will go down to what we class as a trivial level,
which is around 600 ,000.
So anything above that 600 ,000 level
or something that would be fundamental to the controls,
but isn't a financial value, we would bring that to your attention in that follow -up letter.
And the way that we do it, I issue it, I'll issue it to Jonathan, I'll issue it to the
chair and we'll ask that it's circulated around members for your attention.
Quite often that will then come to the next meeting as well as a for information, two
months after we've given the opinion, but it's still helpful for you to have that in
front of you.
That's the way that we would report those and they'd come to your attention.
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:53:00
Thank you. I just hope my wife isn't watching and thinks 600 ,000 is trivial.Can I make a bit of a pat on the back and then a final question?
Again, congratulations to all of you for getting these things done so quickly.
I mean, so much ahead of last year.
I mean, it takes the pressure off us as well.
and also for the way that the information has been produced.
And I know Paula and the team are taking on this idea
of a simplified piece, which I think is really good.
So look forward to seeing that.
And then the final question.
For this, Mazars, how long is your mandate with the council?
You know, will we see you here again,
or is this it type thing?
Speaker - 0:53:50
Yes, I think I can confidently say yes.So we are appointed as the external auditor by public sector audit appointments.
They appoint auditors on a five -year cycle.
I'm going to have to do some mental mathematics.
We are appointed until 2029 -30.
So that is another four years after this year.
You are stuck with us for that period of time.
You are obviously not, because should you be unhappy with the service,
then public sector audit appointments are the body who can make changes to that.
But yeah, we are appointed until 2029 -30,
which incidentally is if those of you who may pay attention to public sector external audit
may be aware there's a body called the local audit office which has been set up now.
You may be aware of the national audit office who have quite a profile in public sector audit.
There's a local audit office that's been set up and they are going to take on the responsibilities
of a number of organisations, including PSAA.
So they will be from 2029 -30,
they will be the body that appoints auditors to councils.
And that's so far in the future.
I'm not giving that any attention or thought at the moment.
Just as a final comment on that,
to give you reassurance from our perspective
and from my perspective,
I am limited by ethical standards,
our firm's processes and PSAA
from being your auditor for five years.
And after five years, I have to rotate off
and go to take on another council
and someone else will come in my place.
And that manages that familiarity risk
that comes from auditors being so long auditing a place
that they have, for want of a better expression,
gone native and not seeing the things that they should see and that makes sure that doesn't happen.
Aaron, I think you want to come back in.
Cllr Jon Byrne - 0:56:12
Speaker - 0:56:17
Just a point on the summary accounts, Philip. That's sector -wide. CITFUR in their callconsultation for 27 -28 have picked this up. I think it's been picked up in numerous audit
committees. So as part of their better reporting group that's also going
forward and there's some simplification of the accounts overall as well coming
through in that consultation of 27 28 so there may be changes in the actual
accounts themselves as well in the next couple of years.
Philip Mills (Co-opted Member) - 0:56:51
Thank you for that. I mean much as I like reading 263 pages I much prefer one side of A4.Cllr Mark Jones - 0:57:01
Thank you, Chair. This is probably to help my understanding. So one thing I noticed Ihadn't appreciated before is that when schools become academies, the transfer of land, if
I understand correctly, we retain the freehold and they only get it on a lease, 125 -year
lease. I'm curious to know if there are any covenants associated with future use of such
land given that we return the freehold. Now that's possibly not a question to answer here,
but it's caught my eye.
I think that would be a question for our estates team.
Yeah.
Speaker - 0:57:35
I think it would be asset disposal.Cllr Mark Jones - 0:57:40
I am interested to know what the situation is. I have one other totally unrelated question.This is below the level of triviality actually.
On 195, it's to do with the airport.
The equity investment and the car park stuff.
Again, curious to know why we got a dividend
the previous year, but not last year.
Because I thought car parks were doing very well.
I know it's only 400K, but.
It's near the top of 195.
Oh sorry it's 134 of the report itself but 195 of the pack.
Speaker - 0:59:12
So, my assumption is that the dividend for 2526 wasn't announced.As we were drafting the statement of accounts, there has been confirmation of a dividend
for 25 -26 there, 25 -26 here at the airports, 25 -26 here around in the last, I think it
was two weeks ago, which it's actually slightly higher in terms of what we've got for 25 -26.
I think it's circa 490K from memory, but that's just from memory.
So there has been a dividend, just to give you that assurance.
We have had a dividend on a car park investment.
Cllr Mark Jones - 1:00:03
Okay, so we're now even more curious,because it is recorded about the dividend for the actual airport holdings itself for 25, 26.
It's just the car park equity investment that's not recorded.
Are they completely separate when they deal with them?
If you've had them 490k I'm very happy.
Speaker - 1:00:39
Yes, in relation to the car park investment, we have had the dividend for 25, 26 and wewe had received one for the year end 24 -25 as well.
Okay, alright, thank you.
Thanks, Jim.
Cllr Mark Jones - 1:00:52
Hopefully we have a share in the finesCllr Jon Byrne - 1:00:54
that they seem to be giving everyone for driving through.Okay, so any other questions, comments?
No?
So, I'm gonna go through that
because this is like a proper thing we have to do.
So we're asked to note the contents of the report
and in the event of no material changes
as the statement of accounts delegate the approval
to the Director of Finance section one by one officer
in consultation with the Chair of Audit Committee
no later than the 31st of January, 2027.
Is that agreed?
Thank you.
Thank you, Alan and Hendrix for coming along as well.
So, we have done, that's the last item.
So, date for future meeting is 9th of December.
So it's not Christmas party.
Thank you very much.
- Minutes of Previous Meeting, opens in new tab
- Internal Audit Progress Report 2 - 2026/27 front sheet, opens in new tab
- Internal Audit Progress Report 2 - 2026/27, opens in new tab
- Chair - AC Effectiveness - Annual Report 2025-26 v final, opens in new tab
- 2025/26 Statement of Accounts, opens in new tab
- Enc. 1 for 2025/26 Statement of Accounts, opens in new tab
- Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council Audit Completion Report 2025-26 -Issued, opens in new tab
Liberal Democrats
The Green Party
Labour and Co-operative Party
Liberal Democrats